All-Season Tire vs All-Weather Tire vs Winter Tires

All-Season Tire vs All-Weather Tire vs Winter Tires

All-season vs all-weather tires comes down to one thing: all-weather tires are built for winter, and all-season tires are not. All-weather tires carry the snowflake symbol and can stay on all year. All-seasons start to lose grip once it drops below about 7°C. Dedicated winter tires still grip best on ice and deep snow. Here's how all three compare in a Nova Scotia winter, and how to pick the right set for the way you drive.

All-Season vs All-Weather vs Winter Tires at a Glance

  All-season All-weather Winter
Best temperature range Above about 7°C Year-round Below about 7°C
Snowflake symbol Usually no Yes Yes
Grip in snow and slush Fair to poor Good Best
Grip on ice Poor Fair Best
Summer driving Best: quiet, long-lasting  Good, but wears faster in heat  Not recommended
Seasonal swap needed? Yes, in winter No Yes, twice a year

What's the Difference Between All-Season and All-Weather Tires?

The names sound alike, but they're built for different jobs.

All-season tires are made for spring, summer and fall. Their rubber gets stiff once it's colder than about 7°C, so they take longer to stop and slide more easily on cold pavement, even with no snow on the ground. They're quiet and long-lasting in warm weather, which is why most new and used vehicles come with them.

All-weather tires use a softer rubber that stays flexible in the cold, plus a tread pattern with more biting edges for snow and slush. They carry the three-peak mountain snowflake symbol, the same severe-snow rating winter tires have. You can leave them on year-round, but they wear a bit faster than all-seasons in summer heat.

All-Weather Tires vs Winter Tires: Which Is Better?

For pure winter grip, winter tires win. Their rubber is even softer, and their deeper tread and many small cuts (called sipes) grip better on ice, packed snow and freezing rain. That matters on a 6 a.m. commute over the bridges, on hills in Dartmouth and Bedford, or on roads outside HRM that don't get plowed right away.

All-weather tires are the middle ground. They're much better in winter than all-seasons and save you the twice-a-year swap, but they give up some ice grip compared with a dedicated winter tire.

Are All-Weather Tires Good Enough for a Halifax Winter?

For many city drivers, yes. All-weather tires are a solid choice if you:

  • Drive mostly in Halifax, Dartmouth and Bedford on main roads that get plowed and salted
  • Can work from home or wait out the worst storm days
  • Don't have the space or the budget for a second set of tires
  • Want one set that's safe in October and still fine in April

Choose dedicated winter tires if you:

  • Commute early in the morning, when roads are most likely to be icy
  • Live in Fall River, Hammonds Plains, Porters Lake, the Valley or anywhere outside the core
  • Drive to New Brunswick or Cape Breton in the winter
  • Want the most grip possible for your family

All-season tires are the one choice we don't recommend for a Nova Scotia winter.

Do You Need Winter Tires in Nova Scotia?

Winter tires aren't required by law in Nova Scotia, unlike Quebec. Studded tires are allowed from October 15 to May 31. Not being required to have them doesn't mean you don't need them, though. Between wet snow, freezing rain and black ice, an all-season tire is the weakest choice for our winters.

Not sure when to make the switch? Our guide to when to put winter tires on in Nova Scotia explains the 7°C rule and the best timing for HRM.

Do AWD Vehicles Need Winter or All-Weather Tires?

Yes. All-wheel drive helps you get moving in snow, but it doesn't help you stop or turn. That comes down to your tires. An AWD SUV on all-season tires will still slide on ice. Our AWD vs FWD in Nova Scotia guide explains when AWD is worth it.

What Does Each Option Cost?

  • All-season only: the lowest upfront cost, but not a safe winter choice here.
  • All-weather: one set of tires, no seasonal swaps and no storage. Expect to replace them a bit sooner than all-seasons.
  • All-season plus winter: two sets to buy, plus a swap in the fall and spring. Each set lasts longer because it's only used half the year, and you get the best grip in every season. Putting your winter tires on their own rims makes each swap quicker and cheaper.

How to Choose the Right Tires

  1. Think about where you drive in January, not July.
  2. Look for the snowflake symbol on any tire you'll use in winter.
  3. Check your current tires. If the tread is close to half worn, or the tires are around six years old or more, it's time to replace them. The four-digit date code on the sidewall tells you the age: "4220" means the 42nd week of 2020.
  4. Always buy four. Never mix tire types on one vehicle.

Get Your Tires at Carson Exports in Dartmouth

Our Tire Centre on Windmill Road can help you choose between all-weather and winter tires for the way you drive, then take care of:

  • New winter, all-weather and all-season tires
  • Installation and balancing
  • Seasonal tire swaps
  • Tire storage, so you don't need room in your garage or basement

Need new tires? Request a quick tire quote online. Already have your set? Book your tire swap or call our service team at 1-833-706-6020. Check our current service specials before you book.

We're at 550 Windmill Road in Dartmouth. Service is open Monday to Friday, 8 a.m. to 5 p.m.

Shopping for a vehicle that's ready for winter? Browse our used SUV inventory or read our guide to the best used AWD SUVs in Halifax.

Tire FAQ

Can I use all-weather tires all year in Nova Scotia?

Yes. That's what they're made for. They carry the snowflake symbol for winter and work fine in summer, though they wear a little faster in hot weather.

Are all-season tires OK in winter?

Not in a Nova Scotia winter. Their rubber stiffens below about 7°C, and most don't carry the snowflake symbol.

Are all-weather tires as good as winter tires?

Close, but not quite. They're good in snow and slush, but dedicated winter tires still grip better on ice and in deep snow.

What does the snowflake symbol on a tire mean?

The three-peak mountain snowflake symbol means the tire has passed a standard test for severe snow. Winter tires and all-weather tires carry it. Most all-season tires don't.

When should I take winter tires off?

Once daytime temperatures stay above about 7°C, usually in April here. Studded tires must be off by May 31.